Are Share Dilutions a Threat For Mining Companies?

Share dilution poses a significant risk to existing shareholders as it can diminish the value of their shares and their proportional ownership in a company. This common phenomenon, known as dilution, warrants careful examination to comprehend its occurrence and the potential implications for shareholders.

‍

Share Dilution Defined

‍

1. Share dilution occurs when a company issues additional stock, leading to a reduction in the ownership proportion of current shareholders. The issuance of new shares dilutes the ownership stakes of existing shareholders.

To illustrate this concept, let's consider a small business with ten shareholders, each owning one share, representing 10% ownership of the company. In this scenario, if voting rights are based on share ownership, each shareholder would have 10% control.

Now, suppose the company decides to issue ten new shares, all of which are purchased by a single investor. As a result, the total number of outstanding shares increases to twenty, and the new investor now holds a 50% ownership stake in the company. Meanwhile, the original shareholders' ownership is diluted to 5% each, as their shares represent a smaller portion of the total outstanding shares.

‍

Causes of Share Dilution

‍

2. Share dilution can transpire through various circumstances, including:

• Conversion by holders of optionable securities: Stock options granted to individuals, such as employees or board members, may be converted into common shares, thereby increasing the overall share count.
• Secondary offerings to raise additional capital: Companies seeking new funds for growth opportunities or to service existing debt may issue additional shares, resulting in dilution.
• Offering new shares for acquisitions or services: In some cases, a company may offer new shares to the shareholders of an acquired firm or to individuals rendering services.
• ‍

Effects of Dilution

‍

3. Dilution is generally viewed negatively by existing shareholders, as it diminishes their ownership stake and, in some cases, their voting power. This reduction in ownership may lead shareholders to perceive a decline in their value within the company. Additionally, when investors with substantial holdings take advantage of smaller shareholders, concerns about dilution can arise.

However, not all instances of dilution are detrimental. If a company issues new stock to raise capital for expansion, the introduction of a new product, or the acquisition of a competitor, it may be viewed as a positive move. Dilution can serve as a means to generate revenue or fund strategic initiatives, potentially benefitting the company and its shareholders in the long run.

‍

‍

Warning Signs of Dilution

‍

4. To protect their investments, retail investors should be vigilant of warning signs that may precede potential share dilution. These signs include emerging capital needs or growth opportunities.

A company may require an equity capital infusion if it needs additional funds to cover expenses or service existing liabilities without taking on additional debt due to existing debt covenants. In such cases, an equity offering through the issuance of new shares may be necessary.

Growth opportunities can also indicate potential dilution. Secondary offerings are commonly utilized to obtain investment capital for large projects and new ventures.

Investors should also pay attention to the granting of stock options to employees, as a large number of optionable securities may lead to future dilution if and when those options are exercised.

‍

Diluted Earnings Per Share (EPS)

‍

5. Investors often seek to determine the value of their shares if all convertible securities were executed, as the execution of these securities reduces the earning power of existing shares. This value is known as diluted earnings per share (EPS) and is calculated and reported in company financial statements.

Diluted EPS is calculated using various methods depending on the circumstances. The "if-converted" method is employed to calculate diluted EPS when a company has potentially dilutive preferred stock. This method involves subtracting preferred dividend payments from net income in the numerator

‍

and adding the number of new common shares that would be issued if the preferred shares were converted to the weighted average number of shares outstanding in the denominator.

Convertible debt can also impact diluted EPS. The if-converted method is applied to convertible debt, where after-tax interest on the convertible debt is added to the net income in the numerator, and the new common shares that would be issued upon conversion are added to the denominator.

Another method used to calculate diluted EPS is the Treasury stock method, which applies to potentially dilutive options or warrants. This method involves subtracting the shares that could be repurchased with the cash received from the exercise of options or warrants from the number of new shares that would be issued upon exercise, and then adding it to the weighted average number of shares outstanding.

Investors should note that certain securities may be considered anti-dilutive, meaning that if converted, EPS would be higher than the company's basic EPS. Anti-dilutive securities do not impact shareholder value and are not factored into the diluted EPS calculation.

Financial statements provide important information about diluted EPS, including basic EPS, diluted EPS, weighted average shares outstanding, and diluted weighted average shares. Footnotes in the financial statements often detail the factors considered in the diluted EPS calculation, such as stock options granted to officers and employees.

In conclusion, dilution poses risks to shareholders as it can erode the value of their shares and reduce their ownership percentage in a company. Recognizing the signs of potential dilution and understanding the impact it can have on the value of shares is crucial for investors. Diluted EPS calculations help assess the effects of dilution on earnings per share, aiding investors in evaluating the financial health and value of their investments.

‍